The Johannesburg Society of Advocates (“JSA”) seeks to participate in the public debate around the appointment of candidates for judicial appointment through the provision of comments on the candidates for judicial appointment. This is done by the JSA as part of its commitment to participatory democracy. These comments are published on the website of the JSA with the consent and knowledge of the Judicial Services Commission.
To see the latest JSC advertisements please click on this link
Reports to JSC April 2014
Comments on JSC Shortlisted Candidates
Click on a name of a Judge to download the report.
Supreme Court of Appeal
Judge NC Erasmus
Judge BM Mbha
Judge PA Meyer
Judge BS Spilg
Judge KGB Swain
Judge CHG van der Merwe
Judge DH Zondi
Electoral Court
Labour Appeal Court
Judge P Coppin
Judge AA Landman
Judge MB Molemela
Judge JR Murphy
Judge DJ Musi
Judge RT Sutherland
Supreme Court of Appeal
Judge N Dambuza
Judge TR Gorven
Judge RS Mathopo
Judge PA Meyer
Judge D van Zyl
Land Claims Court
Judge KE Matojane
Acting Judge President YS Meer
Supreme Court of Appeal
Judge MML Maya
Judge NZ Mhlantla
Judge ZLL Tshiqi
Judge D Pillay
Judge LV Theron
| Title | File Name | Caption |
|---|---|---|
| 20150615 JSA Judicial Candidate Reviews June 2015 | 20150615-JSA-Judicial-Candidate-Reviews-June-2015.doc | |
| 20150921 Judicial Candidate Reviews September 2015 | 20150921-Judicial-Candidate-Reviews-September-2015.doc | |
| Advocate C Prinsloo | Advocate-C-Prinsloo.pdf | |
| Advocate N Davis SC | Advocate-N-Davis-SC.pdf | |
| Advocate R Strydom SC | Advocate-R-Strydom-SC.pdf | |
| Advocate RM Keightley | Advocate-RM-Keightley.pdf | |
| Advocate WHG van der Linde SC | Advocate-WHG-van-der-Linde-SC.pdf | |
| Judge AC Basson | Judge-AC-Basson.pdf | |
| Mr ET Tlhothamaje | Mr-ET-Tlhothamaje.pdf | |
| Mr ML Twala | Mr-ML-Twala.pdf | |
| Mr MPN Mbongwe | Mr-MPN-Mbongwe.pdf | |
| Mr PLC Maseti | Mr-PLC-Maseti.pdf | |
| Mr TP Mudau | Mr-TP-Mudau.pdf | |
| Mrs NP Mali | Mrs-NP-Mali.pdf | |
| Ms CJ Collis | Ms-CJ-Collis.pdf | |
| Ms LT Modiba | Ms-LT-Modiba.pdf |
| Title | File Name | Caption |
|---|---|---|
| Brenner final | Brenner-final.pdf | |
| Collis final | Collis-final.pdf | |
| Consolidated JSA Judicial Candidate Reviews March 2017 | Consolidated-JSA-Judicial-Candidate-Reviews-March-2017.docx | |
| Davis SC final | Davis-SC-final.pdf | |
| Madima SC Final | Madima-SC-Final.pdf | |
| Mahalelo final | Mahalelo-final.pdf | |
| Makhubele SC final | Makhubele-SC-final.pdf | |
| Mokose Final | Mokose-Final.pdf | |
| Sardiwalla Final | Sardiwalla-Final.pdf | |
| Unterhalter SC Final | Unterhalter-SC-Final.pdf | |
| Van der Westhuizen SC Final | Van-der-Westhuizen-SC-Final.pdf |
| Title | File Name | Caption |
|---|---|---|
| Nkosi – Labour Court | Nkosi-Labour-Court.pdf | Labour Court |
| Phahane – Labour Court | Phahane-Labour-Court.pdf | Labour Court |
| Van der Merwe Labour Court | Van-der-Merwe-Labour-Court.pdf | Labour Court |
| Basson – Labour Court | Basson-Labour-Court.pdf | Labour Court |
| Sutherland J – Gauteng – DJP | Sutherland-J-Gauteng-DJP.pdf | Deputy Judge President |
| Mali – Gauteng – HC | Mali-Gauteng-HC.pdf | Gauteng HC |
| Malindi – Gauteng – HC | Malindi-Gauteng-HC.pdf | Gauteng HC |
| Malungana – Gauteng – HC | Malungana-Gauteng-HC.pdf | Gauteng HC |
| Manoim – Gauteng – HC | Manoim-Gauteng-HC.pdf | Gauteng HC |
| Mbongwe – Gauteng – HC | Mbongwe-Gauteng-HC.pdf | Gauteng HC |
| Millar – Gauteng – HC | Millar-Gauteng-HC.pdf | Gauteng HC |
| Moosa – Gauteng – HC | Moosa-Gauteng-HC.pdf | Gauteng HC |
| Munzhelele – Gauteng – HC | Munzhelele-Gauteng-HC.pdf | Gauteng HC |
| Phahlane – Gauteng – HC | Phahlane-Gauteng-HC.pdf | Gauteng HC |
| Wanless – Gauteng – HC | Wanless-Gauteng-HC.pdf | Gauteng HC |
| Crutchfield – Gauteng – HC | Crutchfield-Gauteng-HC.pdf | Gauteng HC |
| Dario – Gauteng – HC | Dario-Gauteng-HC.pdf | Gauteng HC |
| De Villiers – Gauteng – HC | De-Villiers-Gauteng-HC.pdf | Gauteng HC |
| Mtati – Gauteng – HC | Mtati-Gauteng-HC.pdf | Gauteng HC |
| Koen – Gauteng – SCA | Koen-Gauteng-SCA.pdf | SCA |
| Ledwaba – Gauteng – SCA | Ledwaba-Gauteng-SCA.pdf | SCA |
| Matojane – Gauteng – SCA | Matojane-Gauteng-SCA.pdf | SCA |
| Mothle – Gauteng – SCA | Mothle-Gauteng-SCA.pdf | SCA |
| Weiner – Gauteng – SCA | Weiner-Gauteng-SCA.pdf | SCA |
| Carelse – Gauteng – SCA | Carelse-Gauteng-SCA.pdf | SCA |
| Hughes – Gauteng – SCA | Hughes-Gauteng-SCA.pdf | SCA |
| Kollapen (Concourt) | Kollapen-Concourt.pdf | Concourt |
| Ledwaba (Concourt) | Ledwaba-Concourt.pdf | Concourt |
| Mathopo (Concourt) | Mathopo-Concourt.pdf | Concourt |
| Molemela (Concourt) | Molemela-Concourt.pdf | Concourt |
| Unterhalter (Con Court) | Unterhalter-Con-Court.pdf | Concourt |
| Vally (Concourt) | Vally-Concourt.pdf | Concourt |
| Dodson (Concourt) | Dodson-Concourt.pdf | Concourt |
| Kathree-Setiloane (Concourt) | Kathree-Setiloane-Concourt.pdf | Concourt |
